Posts

Showing posts from May, 2024

Burden to prove transaction as commercial is on the Defendant

Image
  Shubham Budhiraja [1]   Mr. A subscribed to the chit tickets of chit fund company. The chit company stopped the business and Mr. A instituted consumer case seeking refund of deposits made in chit fund. The chit company took a plea that Mr. A is not a consumer because transaction is for commercial purpose. The Learned District Forum, Hon’ble State Commission and Hon’ble NCDRC favoured the complainant. The Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under [2] :   (i)              To file a complaint, one must be a complainant and for one to be a complainant, he must be a consumer. If a person fails to come within the definition of a consumer, he cannot be a complainant and therefore, such person cannot file a complaint under the Act.   (ii)            The definition of consumer has three parts. The significance of deconstructing the definition into three part...